Posts Tagged 'search'

Search Sites: Stupid!

DoodleDue to the utter primitiveness of some major internet search sites, I’ve been forced to change some content at StayOnTop.

Amy Winehouse In Pills    The problem was, two pages here (The Pills and Antidepressants With Sex Effects) each had extensive lists of a few hundred brand names of popular antidepressant medications. All those names were given so you could easily look up the specific category (MAOI, SSRI, TCA etc.) of your own antidepressant, and the major known side effects of that category.

    Modern internet search pretends to be ever more refined: they try to make personal profiles of the people who search, so they can adjust the search results to what they think are your personal needs and interests. This is fine (as long as you’re not concerned too much about privacy).

    But when it comes to profiling the actual content they’re listing in their search result pages, they still do a very poor job. Sure, Google has begun trying to filter out “content farms”: websites that have only copied content, and that exist solely for the purpose of showing ads. But on the whole, the search sites still don’t have a clue about what it actually is they are listing as the results for a search.

    It looks like instead of making some kind of actual content analysis, they still rely on simply counting word frequencies to determine what websites are about. This is a kind of Stone Age approach, dating from 1992 or thereabouts, and one that doesn’t really work anymore today.

Dumb Guess

    The result? Probably because of the high frequency of all kinds of medication brand names in the two above-mentioned pages, some search sites (their scanning software, that is) concluded that StayOnTop must be one of those many dubious web shops selling fake medication to a gullible public. They downgraded my site accordingly, so it became harder to find for people searching actual medication info.

    The search whizz kids completely missed the fact that this site is something very different, that those pages of mine were not selling anything at all, and that actually I was warning explicitly and urgently against the dangers of getting medication from dubious sources.

    So because “modern” web search is still this primitive, and because I like new visitors to find this site, I was forced to remove all those brand names. Those two medication pages still do exist here, but their value has been diminished because they will no longer list all the actual brand names. Effectively, the dumbness of web search algorithms forces bloggers like me to remove useful content!

    As a temporary measure, I have saved the original two webpages (the ones that included all those neatly sorted antidepressant brand names) in two PDF files that are less likely to set search software on a false track. So you can still use the full versions, only now you’ll need to download these PDF files:

 
The Pills (PDF file with all antidepressant brand names included)
 
Antidepressants With Sex Effects (PDF file with all brand names included)
 

Vonda ShepardI surely hope that in ten years from now, we’ll no longer see this kind of silly glitches. For now, I hold my breath: let’s hope that our wonderfully smart search sites will not jump to the conclusion that StayOnTop is some kind of porn site because this post included the word “sex” more than once

    Let’s top off all this with some fitting search-song. What about Vonda Shepard? To some, she’s best known for her appearance years ago in the Ally McBeal TV show, but she’s really a great singer. For her last album, do take a look at her website.

Click the Play button below to hear her sing Searching My Soul, with the lines:

I’ve been searching my soul tonight
I know there’s so much more to life
now I know I can shine a light
to find my way back home


(if the player does not work, install Flash)


A Look Through the Hole

This is the first post in the category “Found on the Web”. What more obvious way to begin than with Google? I pinched a hole in this page that leads directly to the Google search results for the words depression psychiatry:
Google Search Results for DepressionI did add the word psychiatry to exclude irrelevant results such as “rain depression” or “the 1930s Great Depression”. As you see, this search leaves us with over 11 million found webpages. A similar search for the words depression psychiatric help produces a similar result – nearly 10 million pages. It would take me a few hundred years to view them all. Of course you can narrow down your search by adding more specific terms like medication or therapy, research, suicide, family, and so on.

    But just like the Web in general, a huge number of all those pages may be discarded anyway as useless, superficial, irrelevant, biased, or even plain nonsense (in my next posts I will show some examples of online nonsense).

MCT: Mango Chutney TherapyWorse, some webpages may be outright dangerous. Anyone can invent some weird new depression therapy and put it online. Suppose I were to invent some hypothetical Mango Chutney Therapy (MCT), you might soon find some webpages saying MCT is a fraud, but also some webpages saying MCT is a great new idea. The Web is full of such contradictory, confusing, and sometimes false information. Finding reliable info online is like finding a needle in a haystack. Sometimes it is even hard to tell whether what you found is the real needle, or just some hay.

    Luckily, Google orders its search results more or less according to what it thinks is relevant. In my 11-million-results query for depression psychiatry, the top result was a general overview of what depression is, from Medscape (which turns out to be run by the WebMD company that covers a wide array of medical information online). This fairly comprehensive page about depression did look reliable. Just don’t forget that sites like that may partly depend on commercial sponsors (sometimes the pharmaceutical industry) and therefore might not always be completely unbiased.

The Protection Of Snake OilThe number two result in my search was a webpage with anti-depression tips by the Royal College of Psychiatrists, a British non-profit organization of professionals. Again this one did look reliable, and even helpful.
    Just be aware that helpful-looking webpages like that might also come from less professional organizations, for example from obscure religious sects. So in other ways they might be even more biased than sponsored commercial sites.

    One general thing to keep in mind is that no one of all those web authors (me included) does know you personally. So if you are looking for some specific advice regarding your own personal problems, in many cases a professional who already knows about your situation might be in a much better position to help and advise, than any webpage written by people who know nothing about you.


 tip: Never just take for granted what you read on the Web. Try to find out where exactly a website’s information comes from: so always first take a brief look at a site’s “about us” or “contact” pages. You won’t know for sure if what they say about themselves is true, but if they say little or nothing about who they are, you will at least know this is not a good sign.
    Also look at indications such as links to other sites, footnotes, references, publication lists that might give you some clue of a site’s background.
    When looking for specific information, always compare a few different websites for what they tell about it.


 


▼ Search Me ...

Today In History:

Arthur Conan DoyleMay 22, 1859 –
Birth date of Arthur Conan Doyle, the Scottish physician and writer who in his popular stories (from 1887 to 1927) created the best known detective ever: the sharply observing and deducing Sherlock Holmes.
   Doyle profiled Sherlock Holmes as an obvious bipolar character, with both manic-active and depressed-lethargic episodes. In the stories, Holmes keeps trying to overcome his periodic depressions by playing the violin (sometimes), smoking (frequently) and using cocaine (as a real addict).
   Portrayed in this way, Doyle's Sherlock Holmes probably was the first popular fiction character suffering from frequent depressions.

If you like to get email notifications about new posts, please enter your email address:

Find Depression News:

For the very latest online news items about depression, try the daily listings at
Topix

       
       

Listed at:

Technorati

OnTopList

BlogCatalog

Health Blogs

Blogarama - The Blog Directory

Alltop, all the top stories

Save as PDF File:

Do you want this webpage in one single file that you can easily save or forward to someone?
Click here to download this page as a PDF file. Conversion will take a few seconds.
 


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 68 other followers