Posts Tagged 'antidepressants'

Floods

Doodle

Depression sometimes looks and feels like a flood. The river of our emotions, that normally runs reasonably within its proper bed, swells beyond control. Of course we can build dikes that are supposed to protect us from a flood disaster. If we are used to depressions, we probably already did build them.

    Antidepressant medication, a therapist, regular physical exercise, doing meaningful work or activities: these are just a few examples of standard measures that can work like dikes. They all can help to keep our depression tendencies at bay, to protect us from being washed away by an uncontrolled sea of negative and self-destructive feelings and impulses.

    Still, we all know that occasionally such dikes are inadequate. In bad times, a particular strong wave of depression may break through or simply run over them. We get flooded. We lose control. The entire landscape of our life begins to look and feel like one somber, gray, monotonous, dangerous, unlivable depression sea:

Flood

So let’s be realistic. Sometimes, in such a situation, there’s little we can do but sitting it out. We temporarily become dependent from others, family or friends or neighbors or health care professionals. We may need those other people to save us from accidentally drowning in the flood of our own depression. They will have to keep reminding us that even when we ourselves think our flood will never go away, in a while it will.

    And this is why, in drier times, we need to set up this kind of last-resort protection to save ourselves in advance from such a potential depression flood.

    As you see I’m in a metaphorical (and somewhat low) mood today. To continue with the metaphor, here is a queer little old building that stands in the middle of nowhere not far from my home. Would you have any idea what this is?

Dry and High

It is a mini power station, built in 1926 to provide a nearby clay mill and some farm houses with electricity. With today’s common power grid, of course it is not in use anymore. But recently, after years of neglect, this thing was restored so it would remain standing as a kind of monument to more primitive times, to antique technology.

    Back when it was built, the river dikes around here were much lower and weaker than today. As a consequence, every few years a serious flood could occur in this area.

    The builders, foreseeing such uncontrollable catastrophes would be inevitable, took their measures. Their “gate” was in fact meant solely as a high kind of base, as a last-resort protection against possible floods. That’s why they built the actual power generator shed on top of it.

High and Dry    Thanks to better dikes, really bad floods don’t happen here anymore. So in this second photo, I did a little photoshopping: just to show you how, with its high gate-like base, this thing was very intentionally designed to survive a worst-case flood scenario.

    For years on end, the high “gate” would serve no real daily purpose; in fact it was rather inconvenient – as you can see, it forced people to install a pulley for hoisting things up to the actual power shed. But for that one single critical week in years, in the rare but possible event of an uncontrollable flood, this high base would prove to be a real life saver.

    I hope you got my point: essentially, it’s the same with a very bad depression. It’s the same in those catastrophic situations when the dikes of our antidepressants, good habits, whatever, prove insufficient: when we ourselves can no longer control the flood of our emotions. When, left to ourselves, we might drown in the gray and seemingly endless tide of our depression.

    In such cases, other people around you (colleagues, friends, even just a neighbor) can function as a life-saving base. They may not be able to prevent the flood itself, but they may very well save you from its worst consequences.

    And exactly like the designers of this strange little building invested beforehand in a brick-and-mortar flood protection base, so you as a depression-prone person should invest beforehand in building a social flood protection base.

    For example, on your better days, try to make it a habit to have a chat or a drink with some neighbor on a regular basis. By doing things like this, you increase the chance that this same neighbor will keep an eye on you. This may be just one of the simple things that can help prevent a disaster, should you yourself ever happen to get completely flooded (and floored) by a severe depression.

Do you see what I mean? OK, then I’ve moralized enough for today

 

Here is the well-known Georgian-British singer Katie Melua with the song The Flood from her 2010 album The House. I want to warmly recommend her; please go the official Katie Melua website for more about her and her many great songs.

    A few months after she recorded this Flood song, Katie Melua herself was hospitalized for six weeks because of “a nervous breakdown”. So believe me, she really does know very well what she’s singing about here:

Katie Melua


(click the green “Play” button – if it does not work, install Flash)


 tip: see above.

• footnote: I took the top photo of an actual flood two years ago in a nearby area that is not protected by dikes.


Postnatal Depression: Dangerous?

DoodleMany women go through a few weeks of “baby blues” during the months after childbirth. Estimates vary from 40% to even 70% of all mothers having had such a temporary emotional setback. Usually a combination of very different causes can contribute to this: specific physical after-birth problems such as incontinency or sore nipples, the daily burdens of new responsibility, doubts if you’re an adequate mother, lack of sleep due to the baby’s crying, hormonal changes, sometimes a certain disappointment because actual motherhood turns out to be different from idealized motherhood, and so on.

    For some, these fairly natural “baby blues” can worsen and instead of fading away again, will grow into a more persistent postnatal depression. Depending from how exactly you define “postnatal depression”, according to modern research roughly 10% to 15% of all mothers develop a more or less serious depression in the year after giving birth. One of the many things that play a role here, is that a case of simple “baby blues” can get worse by itself: this can happen if you start worrying about it, feeling guilty for not being as completely happy as a good mother is supposed to be.

Motherhood    Postnatal depression was already known thousands of years ago; we can clearly recognize it in some old Greek and Roman stories. Since the 19th century, it has gradually got more attention. Today, there are many websites offering background information on causes, symptoms and therapies. So I will not try to do here what many others have already done better. Just find yourself an informative website, preferably one by a trustworthy non-profit organization. Try for example the Postnatal Depression pages of the British National Health Service.

    As you may know I’m not particularly fond of simple online depression tests. I think they are too superficial and often misleading. The standard short 10-question test for postnatal depression is the 1987 Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale.

    If you really want to, you can do this EPDS test online (select your answers and click “add up score” for a result). Just remember that the outcome, whatever it is, is not a hard fact but only a very rough indication.

    If for whatever reason you think you have postnatal depression, you should seek professional help. Without proper attention and treatment, a postnatal depression can take a long time. It will mean a difficult time anyway. But with the right treatment, you will get over it. And although it can be a terrible and maybe even terrifying experience, it is not necessarily dangerous.

Postnatal Psychosis

Friedrich Benjamin OsianderIn a few exceptional cases, about 0.1% (so only one in a thousand), something can happen that is worse than postnatal depression, and in fact is something different: postnatal psychosis (also known as “puerperal psychosis”). The first one who really systematically discerned this, was the German gynecologist/obstetrician Friedrich Benjamin Osiander. In 1797, he gave an extensive description and analysis of postnatal psychosis in his book Neue Denkwürdigkeiten für Aerzte und Geburtshelfer (“New Memorable Facts for Doctors and Obstetricians”).

    Postnatal psychosis can make you not just very depressed, but also very agitated, and often you lose any clear judgment of your own situation. You can get distorted or delusional ideas, start to act in strange or desperate ways. In the most extreme cases you can become a danger to both yourself and your child.

    But something like this will happen only to a tiny minority, and within that little group, the group where such a danger really becomes acute, is even smaller. Perhaps, to put things into perspective, will it help to visualize things here a little? In the diagram below, the group with postnatal psychosis is in fact so small that to show it in proportion, we should have made it completely invisible.

Postnatal Depression DiagramStill, in the few cases where it comes to postnatal psychosis, this can end in catastrophe. Some of these cases are so tragic that they get much publicity – and this publicity can make us think such tragedies happen more often than they actually do.

    Two examples of high-publicity cases: the one of Melanie Blocker-Stokes, who after she had given birth to a healthy daughter developed delusions, began to behave strangely, and a few months later killed herself. And the much-discussed tragedy of Andrea Yates, who in a postnatal psychosis killed all her five children by drowning them in a bathtub.

Paper gown

Although postnatal psychosis does not happen very often, research indicates that the people who already have a past of depression (especially bipolar disorder) are relatively more vulnerable.

Susan Smith    This may (or may not) be illustrated by another high-publicity case. In 1994, Susan Smith drowned her two children (a 3- and a 1-year old) by letting her car, with the children in it, roll into a lake. Just like later with Andrea Yates, there was heated discussion about whether Smith should be seen as a perpetrator, or as a victim.

    Because for nine days after her children’s disappearance she’d kept pretending that they had been kidnapped, and because she was in love with a man who didn’t want children, some saw her simply as a devious, scheming, heartless murderess.

    On the other hand, others pointed out how very likely it was she had been suffering (and acting) from postnatal psychosis, also in view of her past: her father had committed suicide when she was 6, her stepfather had sexually abused her, and she herself had already made two suicide attempts, at age 13 and 18.

    In the end Smith was convicted to life in prison. But still the tragic story of her and her children kept appealing to many, even got something like an emblematic dimension. Do you know the 2008 album Lantana by the wonderful folk singer (country-ish folk singer) Caroline Herring? Her song Paper Gown is directly inspired by this tragedy. In fact, in this song, Herring is trying to give a voice to Susan Smith.

    See the official Caroline Herring website for more of her music (she’s really worth a click). – UPDATE: I just found out her site has now gone offline for a redesign, temporarily redirecting to her Facebook page. So maybe you’ll have to try that instead.
    Anyway, here she is with Paper Gown, singing about how Susan Smith came to kill her children:

Caroline Herring


(click the “Play” button – if it does not work, install Flash)

    

    Meanwhile, do you notice how even I could not resist focusing here on this extreme, dramatic, terrible, but relatively rare aspect of postnatal psychosis? While in fact I was planning to focus on the much less rare, but also less spectacular, more drab aspect of postnatal depression?

    Common postnatal depression is also a terrible ordeal, sure, but usually it will not lead to suicide or killing your children. With some help and support from others, you will be able to overcome it. So let’s conclude with a few basic tips.

Tips:

1. Having the “baby blues”: in the first months after childbirth this is fairly normal, and certainly nothing to feel guilty about. Instead of blaming yourself for not living up to expectations, try to pinpoint what specific causes are making you sad or unhappy at times. Talk openly about this with others.

2. If you continue to feel really very unhappy and inadequate for at least several weeks on end, then you should begin to ask yourself if you’re developing a postnatal depression. Ask for advice; do not hesitate to seek professional help. Maybe you need some kind of temporary therapy. Perhaps even, for a while, a little medication: not all antidepressants are incompatible with breastfeeding.

3. If you have had serious depressions in the past, in the form of bipolar disorder or otherwise, then you may run a slightly higher risk than others to develop postnatal psychosis. Even though the risk will still be very small, in this particular case you should ask the people around you expressly and beforehand to keep a close eye on you: just as an extra safety measure.


• footnote 1: For a little more background info, see this Psychology Today article: Moms Who Kill, by Mark Levy (2002).

Ueber den Selbstmord (1813)• footnote 2: Though largely forgotten now, Friedrich Benjamin Osiander (1759-1822) was an interesting man, and not just because of his pioneering role in the recognition of postnatal psychosis.
    As a professor he wrote many books; another one of them (1813) was Über den Selbstmord, seine Ursachen, Arten, medicinisch-gerichtliche Untersuchung, und die Mittel gegen denselben. Eine Schrift sowohl für Polizey- und Justitz-Beamte, als für gebildete Aerzte und Wundärzte, für Psychologen und Volkslehrer.
    My translation of the title: About Suicide, its Causes, Kinds, Medical-Juridical Investigation, and Means of Prevention. A Book for Police- and Court Officials, trained Doctors and First-Aid Medics, Psychologists and Teachers.
    This 1813 book by Osiander is the only one of his works that is online at Google Books: if you can handle German text in the old-fashioned Fraktur script, it makes a fascinating (but occasionally also very moralistic) read.

• footnote 3: Fathers having postnatal depression? Yes it happens, and while not exactly the same, this is beginning to be recognized a little better. But I didn’t want to make this post more complicated than it already is. So, some other time.


Is Anxiety Depression?

DoodleYesterday, in a brief article Anxiety vs. Depression at Psychology Today, psychiatrist Fredric Neuman tried to explain why psychiatrists often prescribe antidepressant medication even if the patient indicates that her main problem is anxiety or panic attacks rather than depression.

    He states that major depression can often have not a kind of sad feeling as its predominant symptom, but rather anxiety. According to him, when there are also other well-known symptoms such as interrupted sleep, loss of appetite and loss of sexual interest, this specific combination of symptoms can be clear enough for the psychiatrist to diagnose a case as depression: even when the patient would label herself primarily as suffering from waves of anxiety, not from depression.

Panic!    I suppose he may be right – but only, of course, in those cases where (a) this anxiety or panic does indeed come together with other main symptoms of depression, and (b) where this occurs not incidentally but frequently, throughout most days over an extended period.

    Brief as it is, Neuman’s interesting article leaves several important questions unanswered. Here are the two questions that came to my mind immediately:

1. Many people experience anxiety or sudden panic attacks once in while or even frequently. By itself, this may not necessarily be abnormal or an indication of illness; it can for example be caused by actual worries, or by a temporarily overactive self-protection mechanism. Can we be sure that psychiatrists will not jump too easily to the conclusion that such anxiety indicates an underlying depression?
    In other words, can we be sure that psychiatrists will not too easily prescribe antidepressant medication – with sometimes far-reaching and undesirable side effects – even in simple cases where in fact it might be better to just address this anxiety by itself?

2. Neuman does define “depression” but did not really define “anxiety”. So this raises the question what degree of anxiety a psychiatrist should consider bad enough to justify the prescription of antidepressant medication. I suppose this applies to anxiety that is so intense that the patient cannot function normally in daily life anymore. But will it also apply to intermittent feelings of anxiety that the patient merely finds unpleasant or disturbing? Where exactly do we draw the border line between serious anxiety and fairly “normal” anxiety?
    In other words, can we be sure that psychiatrists will not too easily prescribe antidepressant medication even in simple cases where in fact it might be better to explain to the patient that sometimes anxiety (just like grief) is not a kind of aberration but a natural feeling that we should accept as one of the many facets of life?

    Neuman is a qualified anxiety expert (at the Anxiety & Phobia Center of White Plains Hospital) so I hope he will soon give us a follow-up article with a little more of his views on anxiety in relation to depression.


 tip: In my own perhaps too simple view, the best short-term way to counter a frightening, paralyzing, irrational attack of anxiety is this.
    Seek out someone else who at that moment can be more rational than you. Do not yet start a talk about possible causes of your anxiety: for this will often just not work in your present panicky state. Instead, together with this other person try to do something, some kind of simple distracting activity.

• footnote: At the bottom of Neuman’s Psychology Today article is also a link to his personal blog, but due to a typo it will send you to an error page. Here is a link that works.


That Sinking Feeling…

DoodleStill desperately looking for that one definitive anti-depression cure? The one that will act like a life belt, that will keep you afloat on the cold merciless waves of this shoreless, bottomless depression ocean? Worry no longer! I’ve finally found it for you!

    The solution is simple, cheap and tasty. And compared with other antidepressants, it’s perfectly safe too. It’s called Bovril:

The Bovril Antidepressant...

Well, I guess we should be grateful that apparently, this brilliant way to “prevent that sinking feeling” was not known to the British band The Cure. If they had been happy Bovril users when recording their 1985 album The Head on the Door, they might not have been able to describe that same feeling in the song Sinking:

i am slowing down
as the years go by
i am sinking
so i trick myself
like everybody else
 
the secrets i hide
twist me inside
they make me weaker
 
so i trick myself
like everybody else
i crouch in fear and wait
i’ll never feel again
 
if only i could remember
anything at all

The Cure: The Head On The Door


(click the “Play” button – if it does not work, install Flash)

For more music by The Cure, please go to the official The Cure website. The 2006 re-release of the Head on the Door album with this Sinking song can be ordered from Amazon.


• footnote: Of course Bovril is not an antidepressant. It is just a typically English meat extract, a bit like Marmite. Produced since 1870, it was originally meant as “fluid beef” for use by soldiers in the field. Today, it is still used as base for hot drinks, as toast spread, and as flavoring in soups and stews.


Generic Whiskey

Sigmund Freud Whiskey

 tip: Stupidity can be more dangerous than depression.


Search Sites: Stupid!

DoodleDue to the utter primitiveness of some major internet search sites, I’ve been forced to change some content at StayOnTop.

Amy Winehouse In Pills    The problem was, two pages here (The Pills and Antidepressants With Sex Effects) each had extensive lists of a few hundred brand names of popular antidepressant medications. All those names were given so you could easily look up the specific category (MAOI, SSRI, TCA etc.) of your own antidepressant, and the major known side effects of that category.

    Modern internet search pretends to be ever more refined: they try to make personal profiles of the people who search, so they can adjust the search results to what they think are your personal needs and interests. This is fine (as long as you’re not concerned too much about privacy).

    But when it comes to profiling the actual content they’re listing in their search result pages, they still do a very poor job. Sure, Google has begun trying to filter out “content farms”: websites that have only copied content, and that exist solely for the purpose of showing ads. But on the whole, the search sites still don’t have a clue about what it actually is they are listing as the results for a search.

    It looks like instead of making some kind of actual content analysis, they still rely on simply counting word frequencies to determine what websites are about. This is a kind of Stone Age approach, dating from 1992 or thereabouts, and one that doesn’t really work anymore today.

Dumb Guess

    The result? Probably because of the high frequency of all kinds of medication brand names in the two above-mentioned pages, some search sites (their scanning software, that is) concluded that StayOnTop must be one of those many dubious web shops selling fake medication to a gullible public. They downgraded my site accordingly, so it became harder to find for people searching actual medication info.

    The search whizz kids completely missed the fact that this site is something very different, that those pages of mine were not selling anything at all, and that actually I was warning explicitly and urgently against the dangers of getting medication from dubious sources.

    So because “modern” web search is still this primitive, and because I like new visitors to find this site, I was forced to remove all those brand names. Those two medication pages still do exist here, but their value has been diminished because they will no longer list all the actual brand names. Effectively, the dumbness of web search algorithms forces bloggers like me to remove useful content!

    As a temporary measure, I have saved the original two webpages (the ones that included all those neatly sorted antidepressant brand names) in two PDF files that are less likely to set search software on a false track. So you can still use the full versions, only now you’ll need to download these PDF files:

 
The Pills (PDF file with all antidepressant brand names included)
 
Antidepressants With Sex Effects (PDF file with all brand names included)
 

Vonda ShepardI surely hope that in ten years from now, we’ll no longer see this kind of silly glitches. For now, I hold my breath: let’s hope that our wonderfully smart search sites will not jump to the conclusion that StayOnTop is some kind of porn site because this post included the word “sex” more than once

    Let’s top off all this with some fitting search-song. What about Vonda Shepard? To some, she’s best known for her appearance years ago in the Ally McBeal TV show, but she’s really a great singer. For her last album, do take a look at her website.

Click the Play button below to hear her sing Searching My Soul, with the lines:

I’ve been searching my soul tonight
I know there’s so much more to life
now I know I can shine a light
to find my way back home


(if the player does not work, install Flash)



▼ Search Me ...

Today In History:

John ClareMay 20, 1864 –
Poet John Clare (70) dies peacefully in the Northampton General Lunatic Asylum where he had been living his last 23 years. Due to his background and his knowledge of nature, in his own time he was known as “The Northamptonshire Peasant Poet”.
   Originally an uneducated farmhand, as a successful poet he had felt out of place everywhere: not at home among simple villagers anymore, but not at home among his more refined reader public either.
   Besides deep depressions he also suffered from periods of delusion: thinking he was Shakespeare or Byron, he had set about rewriting their poetry.
   One of his best known poems, I Am, written in the asylum shortly before he died, expressed loneliness and a longing for both the innocence of childhood and the blissful emptiness of death.

If you like to get email notifications about new posts, please enter your email address:

Find Depression News:

For the very latest online news items about depression, try the daily listings at
Topix

       
       

Listed at:

Technorati

OnTopList

BlogCatalog

Health Blogs

Blogarama - The Blog Directory

Alltop, all the top stories

Save as PDF File:

Do you want this webpage in one single file that you can easily save or forward to someone?
Click here to download this page as a PDF file. Conversion will take a few seconds.
 


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 67 other followers